The stone restoration to the tower of the St James Old Cathedral in West Melbourne is nearing completion.

At least six different stone types have been identified in the tower construction, by James Mann, Dimension Stone Testing Specialist from South Australia. These include the unusual and unique ferruginised sandstone, possibly quarried within or near the Melbourne Botannical Gardens. Information on this quarry has been supplied by Professor Miles Lewis, including the early drawing below which shows the quarry converted to a fern gully.

A white sandstone is likely to have been quarried near Kangaroo Point in Tasmania, which was imported into Melbourne from c1840. Other sandstones, ranging from yellow, green and brown, would have been quarried within the Melbourne environs and out to Bacchus March.

Further investigation exposed recycled and inverted stone blocks from other buildings, with carved patterning such as coin moulding and fluted columns (shown below).

Construction of the former cathedral began c. late 1830s and was originally located on the corner of Williams and Little Collins Streets, replacing an earlier modest timber church building.

Two architects are associated with the building, Robert Russell and Charles Laing. It is the only building designed by Robert Russell to survive. He was the government architect and surveyor during the early development of Melbourne. It is one of only a few major buildings in Melbourne from the pre-gold Rush era (prior to 1851) and the only remaining example of the Regency church style.

The ST Gill drawing above, from 1857, illustrates that the original location of the cathedral and tower (in the red box) was a very visible landmark on the Melbourne skyline of that era.

In 1912, the building was condemned by the Health Department, which prohibited services from being held on the valuable site. Members of the Anglican community rallied to preserve the stone building and it was relocated to the current site c.1914 with some alterations, especially to the tower. This is probably when the recycled blocks were incorporated.

01 March 2012

Related Posts

21 June 2023

2023 AIA Victorian Architecture Awards

The 2023 Awards ceremony for the Victorian Australian Institute of Architects was held on Friday the 16th June.

Several representatives from RBA Architects and Conservation Consultants attended the event, where we were proud to receive an Award for Heritage Conservation for the Prahran Arcade Façade Conservation and a Commendation for Heritage – Conservation for the restoration of Doherty House in Tarneit.

Additionally, we were pleased to see Searle x Waldron receive an Award for Architecture for the Joyce Chapel Bridge and Wardle receive The William Wardell Award for Public Architecture for the Bendigo Law Courts – both projects that RBA have been involved in.

Learn more about the Prahran Arcade Facade Conservation here

Learn more about the Doherty House Restoration here

Doherty House, Tarneit (Image: Thurston Empson)

Bendigo Law Courts, Wardle (Image: Tim Griffith)

Prahran Arcade (Image: Thurston Empson)

Joyce Chapel Bridge, Searle x Waldron (Image: Peter Bennetts)


05 May 2023

RBA Projects Shortlisted for the 2023 AIA Victorian Architecture Awards.

At the recent AIA awards event, it was announced that two of RBA’s recent projects, the Prahran Arcade Façade Restoration and Doherty House, have been…

05 September 2022

Frozen in time, we’ve become blind to ways to build sustainability into our urban heritage

  The Walsh Bay Arts Precinct development won the Greenway Award for Heritage. MDRX/Wikimedia, CC BY-SA James Lesh, Deakin University It was hard to keep…

02 October 2020

Staff news: celebrating 20 years with Anthony Hemingway

This year marks two decades of distinguished service for an integral member of RBA: Senior Associate and Architectural Historian, Anthony Hemingway. Anthony started at RBA…